Saturday, July 11, 2009

do you think drugs should be legalized.??..think again...

I was jolted out of my morning blues with one half being in the dream where my friend is still debating on the point that “Narcotic drug should be legalized in India” and my other half highly disheartened of the fact that its 8:20 on the clock. As I got on with my morning ablutions, the thoughts of last night talks haunted me and I was deeply moved by some of views of my friend.

According to him narcotic drugs should be legalized because

1.Right now the budget allotted for the rehabilitation of the drug addicts is very negligible or in other sense they are neglected. so if you legalize it then, the revenue obtained would be more and can be used for rehabilitation processes in a better way and can be used for generating awareness among masses about its harmful effects.
2.The crime level comes down drastically.
3.The money spend on the proceedings of court cases related to narcotic drugs sale and distribution can be avoided by which you are saving the revenue of the state.

Keeping in mind the problems faced by the contemporary India and of being a student of sociology it was not that easy for me to digest it .So as the first step of its analysis I started searching for its dictionary meaning of narcotic because my friend said there are many narcotic drugs which are not that addictive and cause problems, and dictionary says:

narcotic /nar·cot·ic/ (nahr-kot´ic)
1. pertaining to or producing narcosis.
2. an agent that produces insensibility or stupor, especially an opioid.Harmful and highly addictive if used repeatedly.

And if you analyze the entire range of narcotic drugs you would find that majority are addictive in nature and cause mental instability. Now one might claim that it can be used as an pain killer and for other therapeutic use .But by making it legalized and letting the common people use freely wont lead to its appropriate use especially in a country like India where bribery, adulteration ,trafficking and vested interest are the mindset of the people will lead to its absolute misuse.

Secondly, looking into the crimes associated with the narcotic drugs sale, distribution and the crimes committed by people who gets addicted by these drugs, one would find that in current scenario crimes of the former kind is higher than the latter kinds of crimes as claimed by my friend. So my friend says if you legalize it then crimes of the first kind will disappear and the crime as a whole would eventually come down. Now to think that way is a different level of irrationality because to decrease crime which is nothing but violation of law you change the definition of law it self, by which it is no longer a crime and hence claiming that the crime rate is reduced is highly illogical.
But does the immorality associated with this act get washed away??.NO,before immorality was associated with people who were selling it and once it is legalized it is the state ,the immorality factor has just shifted from some people to the state.

Thirdly, let’s assume that we have made narcotic drugs legalized. In such a situation every “paan” shop and every petty shop which are selling cigarettes and “gutkas” would now starts selling narcotic drugs in various forms. And majority of people who consumes gutka’s and cigarettes would switch to drug variant of these. People who take breaks between their work to “fag”of the pressure will start to “dope” of the pressure .And then different varieties of “indigenous drugs “will also come into the market and spurious forms of these will lead to different social tragedies. The biggest example is the fact that alcohol which is legalized in India is causing a lot of major social problems. The mirror image of these problem is the recent hooch tragedy. One can’t even visualize its social implications. Death toll reached 112,think of those family who lost their beloved ones, who were the only earning member of the family ,think of the mother’s who lost their sons and those sister’s who lost their loving brother. I know its hard to think unless it happens to one,right. Its implication in society does not stop there. This has resulted in a political clash between the major parties of the place . The “bandh” organized has affected schools, colleges, shops and all the major institutions of the state, the harmony of the state is disturbed.112 dead many more in the critical situation .If alcohol was not legalized then tragedies of these kinds won’t have happened in such a larger sphere.

The above example just implies that things of narcotic nature will cause mental instability in the society and in case of drugs its going to be more severe because if majority get addicted then the very existence of society looks bleak and hazy. If people itself is not there to listen to, whom will you give awareness with the revenue obtained as a part of legalizing drugs. And about the crimes its highly illogical to change the laws to abate its violation ,to reduce crime. And we should not forget that when one crime stops, another would appear for eg:if drug is legalized then drug trafficking(which now is severely punishable by law and is controlled to a large extend) would emerge has one of the major crime and controlling that would be impossible because only if victims are in their senses they can refuse and retaliate or help find the criminals . So eventually in india crime would rise . On the other hand it might be true that there must be places were drugs would have made legalized and things would have become better ,that’s because of the reasons that the administration over there would have been very effective in regulating it, at the same time majority of the people over there would be well aware of the harmful effect of narcotic drugs. And very interestingly you would not find the strong family values in those places. In short legalizing narcotic drugs in India in current scenario would eventually lead to serious crimes , physically and mentally would weaken the majority of young people who is the backbone of developing India and eventually ,causing a instability in society which would hamper the traditional values and pluralism which is the Soul of India.

7 comments:

  1. firstly commenting on the topic i would say that when changing defination of law as said
    in above
    "Now to think that way is a different level of irrationality because to decrease crime which is nothing but violation of law you change the definition of law it self, by which it is no longer a crime and hence claiming that the crime rate is reduced is highly illogical"
    it is not ur crime rate i was talking abt..its the hassles and the pains faced by the country when fighting this prolonged court battle and the social,economical and practical implications to the people and the country is very clear.

    Secondly talking abt hoonch incident, FYI alcohol in Gujarat is banned. So ppl experiment with whtever comes to thr hand.they pay extra money to acquire it which itself is used to promote illegal activities.
    Rather say if it was legalized probably quality controls r possible. rates r lower n plus benifiet is back to ppl as government is putting back the money into circulation.Compare the scenario of legalizing it with current scenario.There would have been no hoonch incident altogether.

    Thirdly India has its moral fiber intact n that is the reason still in India alcohol is not something which families are proud of..we dont have mini bars at our houses..and onthe other hand the ban of Cigs at Public places has not decreased its use.So instead of passing the huge profit of drugs money to Underworld which r promoting various other crimes if this is taken away i would say they would go through an era of recession.

    ReplyDelete
  2. i agree to the fact in gujarat it was never legalised..i was a fault from my part.but one can take away only the legality part of the issue,the social impact still remains because the spurious liquor problem happened in the other states where it is legalized is more worse.In last two years there has been many cases in orrisa,kerala and andhra pradesh ,jharkhand ,tamil nadu where social impact was drastic,many people died and many lost their vision (esp in kerala 2 major cases)and most importantly all the states it is legalised.Finally,In the current scenario where India is moving towards westernization, legalizing of drugs is going to seriously affect those young people who we believe will shoulder the responsibility of preserving Indian values,pluralism and growth.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Morality is subjective.

    What is moral for u may be immoral for me and vice versa. So there is no point talking about a collective morality/immorality

    You talk of mental instability. Drinking also causes mental instability right?

    Yes, drugs are addictive. Very addictive. But then so is cigarette. Maybe not as addictive, but addictive none the less. Also, drugs dont damage ur internal organs like cigarette/smoking does. I am sure you have seen the statistics: the number of people dying of smoking related issues is not a small number at all...so then y is smoking not illegal?

    Y is drinking not illegal?


    Portugal decriminalized drugs. it is only an administrative offense and not a criminal offense. This alone has caused the number of drug related crimes in portugal to drop like a rock.

    Everything else i want to say has already been mentioned above...

    ReplyDelete
  4. @thor
    Morality is subjective.

    What is moral for u may be immoral for me and vice versa. So there is no point talking about a collective morality/immorality

    I agree to the fact that it is subjective and its true what is moral for me might be immoral for you.But don't you think we Indians have common moral values or collective morality/immorality as you say??..we do have many things in common,to name a few,majority of people believe in monogamy,we value our family relationships,we have high respect for our parents,we don't appreciate extra marital affairs,we don't appreciate prostitution,irrespective of different religions we have all believe ,god is the supreme one.if there was no collective moral values you will never see large get-togethers in societies during social functions.Biggest example is marriages, majority of people believe it is something sacred that's the reason why we have religious rituals and unless it is done we don't consider it as a marriage.

    we still believe that "living relationship" and "wife swapping"(these cases very common in metro's) is immoral.All these may be moral for some but when i say "we" its the majority of people of India.so one can't deny the collective morality/immorality.And all these are the signs of westernization in such a scenario how can we jeopardise our people by legalizing drugs??..and i don't appreciate legalized state of tobacco or alcohol .

    ReplyDelete
  5. @ thor
    Portugal decriminalized drugs. it is only an administrative offense and not a criminal offense. This alone has caused the number of drug related crimes in Portugal to drop like a rock.

    In July 2001 Portugal decriminalized the use, possession and acquisition of all types of illicit substances for personal use,but these changes did not legalize drugs in Portugal.Possession has remained prohibited by Portuguese law and criminal penalties are still applied to drug growers, dealers and traffickers.they made this law stringent and authorities have to be appreciated for reducing the drug supply which lead to the reduce in crimes.
    But one can't compare portugal and India?

    BY 2001 CENSUS
    population of india
    is 1,028,737,436=1.02 BILLION,
    population of portugal
    is 10,355,824=10.35 MILLION (APPROX 1% OF INDIA)

    secondly,portugal is a developed country.
    India is still a developing country.

    thirdly, their administrative system is far more effective because of less population and comparatively less corruption is there.

    fourthly literacy rate of India 65%,ie 35% of 1.02 billion is illiterate.literacy rate of Portugal is 93%.ie only 7%of 10.35 million or
    7%(1% Indian population).By 2001 census adult literacy rate was 95% in Portugal and 2007 it is 100%.with this high literacy rate , its no surprise if Portuguese have controlled crimes there.

    India with such high illiterate population and highly corrupt authorities, crimes like drug trafficking will exponentially increase with legalization of drugs and it will be uncontrollable.

    with this high population and innumerable number of different communities and beliefs ,and to add on the inefficient and ineffective administration it is highly impossible to regulate drugs in India.May be in a developed country like Portugal were population is 1%of India's population and with 90% of christian population the culture is pretty much the same,so less diversity,100% adult literacy rate (93% overall)and a effective administration would have reduced crime with decriminalization of drugs.India with highly contrasting features, drug legalization would make its future bleak.

    ReplyDelete
  6. @jags ,thor
    drugs is just a way ppl find to escape from their misfortunes and their fkd up lives
    stop it ... those who are desperate will still go for it
    reahabilitate tehm
    tats the only way
    i dont think makin it legal will help
    coz , if u really c ..
    its not wat the drug users think tat matters.
    its really not his call.Coz whoever this guy is , with his amazing vision for a crime free world by making drugs legal, doesnt realize there are a hundred other dumb guys who just think that drugs is cool....unfortunately, the world cares about them too...
    you want drugs, go to portugal

    ReplyDelete
  7. k thor..srry for that shit..some points still hold but i think decriminalizing is not such a bad idea...i thot u meant legalizing ! :) .. but i guess jags has a point tooo..but decriminalizing does give us a platform to get rid of so many underground actvities....

    ReplyDelete